Offer for Commercial Tenant Proposal (Housing Hilltop South)
The submission period ended on June 24, 2024.
Respond to:
Nicholas Carr
ncarr@tacomahousing.org
Or
Tacoma Housing Authority
Re: OCTP
c/o Nicholas Carr
902 S L St
Tacoma, WA 98405
Introduction and Summary
Design the Hill
“Design the Hill” began in 2016 as an embedded and inclusive community engagement process to transform 3 sites owned by Tacoma Housing Authority (THA) for the benefit of the surrounding Hilltop community; it focused on three broad tenets
- Social + Spatial Equity = Thriving Hilltop
- Equitable revitalization in Hilltop is dependent on Community-Driven Design
- Opportunities for Economic Empowerment of existing residents are essential within this framework
Resilient Neighborhoods and Anti-Displacement Efforts
As Design the Hill commenced, the community was starting to see signs of gentrification and wanted to do everything possible to limit resident housing and business displacement by planning for and enacting actions that supported community resiliency and antidisplacement in the Hilltop neighborhood
As the Design the Hill Community Plan was finalized THA, its planning partners, and the community agreed on some critical goals, as memorialized in the final plan:
- Create housing that is affordable to households 0-60% AMI
- Develop a community priority plan which will prioritize applications from current Hilltop residents and those who have been displaced or are at risk of displacement from the neighborhood
- Providing commercial and retail space, with a focus on affirmative marketing and supporting small, locally-owned businesses
Timeline
| Date | |
|---|---|
| Proposal Deadline: | June 24 @ 5PM |
| Applicant Notification 1: | July 5 |
| Applicant Notification 2: | July 15 |
| Final 5 Interviews: | July 22-26 |
| Final Decision: | August 1 |
| Lease Negotiations: | Begin August 5 |
| Space Build-out: | Begin August 16 |
Cold Shell Specifications
3000 square feet of total commercial “cold shell” space conceptualized as 3 separate businesses:
- Space A 1501 SF +288 SF patio
- Space B 296 SF
- Space C 775 SF
THA has included predevelopment investment for prospective tenants, including two (2) ADA bathrooms with shared hallway access for all tenants, and significant electrical work, including panels, and shared HVAC tie in for future installation. There is a grease trap in Space A.
The cold shell has 4 entrances from 11th St, with the east most space having access to an enclosed patio. There is no building maintenance or support access to the rear of any of the shell. This means garbage removal, product delivery, etc. will need to be done through the front street facing doors. There will be street parking on 11th St and side streets, but there will be no dedicated parking for employees or visitors within the building garage. Marketing signage will be negotiated with all chosen tenants and THA at a later date.
- Bathrooms and shared hallways space include instant hot water units, lighting, exit signage, fire alarms, and a shared utility/storage room
- Electrical work includes 200A panels, freeze protection electric heaters, and fire alarms for each of the three conceptualized spaces
The detailed floorplan for the commercial space is shown in Exhibit A at the end of this proposal and will be available as a PDF by request.
Proposal Requirements
Business Recruitment
THA is looking for passionate, creative, and qualified applicants to propose business opportunities for our newest development, Housing Hilltop. THA will evaluate the submissions using a transparent set of guidelines with input and support from independent community leaders and local professionals.
Please submit your package by June 24, 2024. Format your response in a style that you are comfortable with, but please ensure that it that includes responses and documentation to the following evaluation criteria, financial qualifications, and resources as outlines in sections A through D.
A. Evaluation Criteria Questions
- Tell us about your business/concept. What do you love about what you do? Why does it fit the space? How does it fit the Hilltop community? What excites you about this opportunity? Please elaborate on your vision! Tell us who you are and why you are giving us the opportunity to choose you.
- THA’s market rental rates are $21 per square foot, plus applicable tenant costs as outlined in Lease Expectations below; what sales and/or service goals would you need to over the rental rate for this property? Please provide us some insight in this answer.
- Are you a small business? (Using RCW 19.85.020, “small business” means any business entity, including a sole proprietorship, corporation, partnership, or other legal entity, that is owned and operated independently from all other businesses, and that has fifty or fewer employees.)
- Are you a member of a historically marginalized group? (Using a definition from the International City/County Management Association, 2022, “historically marginalized groups” are people who have faced deliberate and long-term exclusion from involvement in or access to cultural, social, political, and economic activities. People in these groups are often marginalized because of their race, ethnicity, immigration status, gender, sex, or sexual orientation. Indigenous, Black, people of color, immigrant, women, transgender, non-binary, lesbian, and gay communities are often considered historically marginalized populations.)
- Do you consider yourself a member of the Black community?
- Are you a current or previous resident of Hilltop? Do you currently operate (or have you previously operated) a business in Hilltop? Are you at risk of displacement? Why do you want to move or start your business here?
- Do you have community support? What is the potential (and current) impact of your business on the local community? Does your proposal fit the needs and character of the neighborhood? Letters of reference and letters of support are welcome and encouraged.
B. Financial Qualifications
- Do you have a business plan and business experience? What is your history of business operations, including achievements, growth, and resilience to hardship?
- What is your current financial situation? Is your business financially viable? Do you have access to, or need, capital resources? Are you able to show us documentation to support your proposal?
- Do you require some financial support if you are considered for one of these spaces? How much?
C. Financial Support
The architectural, permitting, and construction costs to turn a cold shell into a commercial shell starts at about $100,000 per 1000 square feet, with costs increasing as design and finishes are customized. THA has secured some financial resources to build out the commercial space (totaling $610,000 split between the space by square foot) that must be spent by December 31, 2024. These resources are limited to specific uses as outlined below, and will be managed by THA in service to the commercial improvements. Please include how these resources will strengthen your proposal.
The Chase grant funds will be reserved for commercial improvement needs. Plumbing may not be included outside of the already constructed bathrooms. These Chase funds will be managed and completed by THA. This means that once the tenants have been chosen and we proceed with leasing and move-in, THA will consult with new tenants, but the work completed using these funds will be in service to the space and will remain with the space and owned by THA.
D. Additional Resources
We have also identified below some additional opportunities for financial or technical support, please also include if these resources are 1) necessary for you to utilize, and if not necessary, 2) are you still interested and planning to contact the providers to support your proposal?
1. Washington Minority Business Development Agency – Tacoma Business Center
The Tacoma office of the MBDA can help minority-owned businesses access to capital. This includes bonding assistance, identifying financing opportunities, and matchmaking with banking institutions or mezzanine financing options. It also includes connecting businesses with alternative lenders for the financing of purchase orders or rapid scalability.
Contact: Frank Boykin; fboykin@cityoftacoma.org
2. The city’s Economic Development Services include some specific opportunities that may be of interest to respondents, including their Business Incentives page and their Small Business Loan Program, which offers:
- Small Business Revolving Loan Fund
- Micro-loan Revolving Loan Fund
- Grow America Fund
- Historic Rehabilitation & Repair Loan
- Fire Safety Loan
- Business Façade Improvement Loan
Contacts:
Carol Wolfe; cwolfe@cityoftacoma.org, (253) 591-5384
Debbie Bingham; dbingham@cityoftacoma.org, (253) 591-5117
3. THA is partnering with the Tacoma-Pierce County Black Collective to help support respondents. The Black Collective may be able to offer:
- Business plan support
- Financial resource guidance
- Business expansion strategies
Contact: Michael Jordan; mjordan@bcbnavigator.org
Lease Expectations
Lease Terms
5-year initial term with negotiable extension options available.The commercial space is located within a larger affordable housing property that has been financed with a number of sources. All uses of the commercial space, as well as the Lease form, must comply with requirements of the existing funders, as well as the terms of a Commercial Space Sublease (the “Sublease”) between Housing Hilltop LLLP and THA.
Prohibited Uses
The Sublease provides that certain uses of the commercial space are not permitted. Please see Exhibit B for a list of prohibited uses.
Evaluation Process
Proposal Deadline
June 24, 2024
Submit packages to Nicholas Carr via email at ncarr@tacomahousing.org or drop them off at THA c/o Nicholas Carr.
THA Administrative Offices are located at 902 S L St, Tacoma, WA 98405.
THA will consider late submissions with acceptable reasoning.
Preliminary Review: Applicant Notification 1
THA staff will review all submissions with a “review team” consisting of THA employees, city representatives, and community leaders. Each applicant will be scored individually by members of the review team; after scoring is done, the review team will review the applicants together before collectively making decisions on the next round.
- Applicants moving on to the next round of the process will be informed, and may have additional requirements or questions to respond to.
- Applicants who are not chosen will receive acknowledgement and thanks, and will have clear messaging on why they won’t be moving to the next round.
Secondary Review: Applicant Notification 2
The review team will consider those proposals making it past the preliminary stage, analyzing the requests for further information (if applicable), and will choose up to 5 applicants to interview for a final decision.
Interviews: Final 5 Applicants
Five final applicants will be interviewed by the review team. These interviews will provide additional information and context for consideration by THA Leadership.
Final Decision
Based on the final five applicants’ proposals and interviews, THA Leadership (consisting of multiple departments) will choose the 3 businesses to be offered space at Housing Hilltop South.
Scoring Rubric
The scoring rubric that the review team will use to evaluate applicants is located in this proposal as Exhibit C.
Post-section Process
Prospective tenants will meet with THA to review lease terms and conditions, shell space needs and tenant improvement process, move-in timeline, signage, and operational starts dates. The build-out process is conceptualized as an iterative partnership between THA and all 3 tenants. The process will include:
- Space design concepts
- Cost estimates
- Design/engineering
- Permitting
- Construction
- Inspections
- THA/City of Tacoma final approvals
- Lease execution
- Open for business
